Greed and Fear—How To Avoid The Whiplash and Sleep At Night

Treat those two imposters just the same
Markets in the Mirror: When Sentiment, Policy, and Data Collide
The past two months delivered a masterclass in market psychology.
April gave us panic.
May gave us euphoria.
Neither was tethered to fundamentals.
From algorithmic stampedes to political noise fatigue, investors are relearning the painful truth: narrative is not data. Here’s what really moved markets—and what you can learn from the misfires.
Greed vs. Fear: A 67-Point Mood Swing

In just six weeks, the CNN Fear & Greed Index swung from 4 (Extreme Fear) to 71 (Greed).
That 67-point lurch was more violent than anything we saw during the 2022 bear market.
- April: Tariff shocks and a Moody’s downgrade spooked markets. The S&P 500 fell to 4,160, wiping out $9 trillion in equity value.
- May: Dip buyers and institutional flows stepped in. The S&P rallied 17% off the lows, adding $400B in market cap per day.
- Even Bitcoin wasn’t immune—its Fear & Greed Index surged from 10 to 66.
Lesson: When sentiment hits extremes, it’s often a signal to do the opposite.
April’s fear was a contrarian buy.
May’s greed may be an early warning.
Trump’s Tariff Theater: The T.A.C.O. Pattern

T.A.C.O. = Trump Always Chickens Out
That’s how Barclays now labels Trump’s recurring trade threats: high on volume, soft on follow-through.
Markets are adapting:
- Tariff noise rattles soft data (like sentiment surveys), but barely touches hard data (earnings, rates, trade flows).
- The VIX barely flinched in May. Wall Street seems to view Trump’s bluster as theater, not policy.
Takeaway: Investors may be desensitized to political shocks—a risky complacency if a real crisis breaks through.
Dalio’s Crisis of Credibility

Ray Dalio warned in May of an “imminent financial crisis.”
Reality had other plans:
- The S&P rose 6.2%.
- Bitcoin rallied 14%.
- Corporate earnings climbed 8% YoY.
- U.S. tax receipts hit a record $4.9T (FY 2025).
Not the first time:
- In 1981, Dalio predicted a depression. A bull market followed.
- Between 2023–2025, while warning of collapse, the S&P returned 34%.
Key Miss: Dalio’s models overweight debt and geopolitics—but underestimate resilient fundamentals like earnings, cash flow, and innovation.
Even legends can lag reality. Don’t outsource your thinking to macro celebrities.
Bifurcated Markets: Institutions vs. Headlines
We’re in a two-track market:
- Institutions are trading on yields, cash flow, and volumes.
- Retail investors are reacting to headlines and vibes.
Opportunity lives in the gap.
Those who can tell signal from noise—win.
3 Principles for Market Sanity
1. Sentiment is cyclical
• Use extremes in fear/greed as contrarian indicators—not confirmation.
2. Political noise fades
• Earnings and interest rates outlast soundbites.
3. Data > Gurus
• Build a system based on signals—not talking heads.
AI Is Quietly Rewriting Strategy—Far Beyond Search
Forget chatbots. AI’s real revolution is reshaping business, medicine, and media behind the scenes.
1. AI-Powered Business Strategy
Upload customer data + value props → Get instant go-to-market plans, pitch decks, and brand strategy.
2. Diagnostics Without Waiting Rooms
- Spectral AI’s DeepView diagnoses burn wounds with 95%+ accuracy.
- AI tools now review labs, symptoms, and history—no co-pay, no waiting.
- AlphaSense automates medical research at enterprise scale.
3. Earnings Call Disruption
- Zoom and Klarna used AI avatars in investor calls.
- AI highlights facts, strips fluff, and flags evasive statements.
4. Automated Podcasting at Scale
- Tools like Jellypod can clone your voice, convert articles to episodes, and publish—no mic needed.
5. The Human-AI Imperative
- Interpret: AI finds patterns. You apply meaning.
- Audit: AI has blind spots. You provide context.
- Leverage: Scale thought leadership, don’t outsource it.

Charts/In the Markets
Silver: a hot week relative to its big brother, gold
- Silver bugs have been calling for a breakout for…a decade.
- It broke $35/oz - next stop $50.

Watch Relative Value—Focus on The Ratios
- USD crushed by gold—last 5 years.
- USD crushed by Bitcoin—last 5 years


- Divide one asset priced in USD.
- By another asset priced in USD.
- Takes the depreciating USD out of the equation.
- Leaves just relative strength.

What’s Next/What To Watch
- Check out Jim Bianco on the consistently excellent Forward Guidance podcast discussing how 5% 10-year rates will become the new floor.
- For a check-in with Freedom Caucus member Senator Ron Johnson, watch the boys at All-In figure out the Senate fate of One Big Beautiful Bill.
- Don’t forget to compare the Non-Farm Payrolls this Friday, June 6th—consensus 125,000—130,000 with April’s 177,000. If the NFP number undershoots, the markets will likely trade up on the expectation that the Fed is more likely to ease, and vice versa.
- And, get some popcorn and watch the Trump/Musk relationship meltdown on X—with the Tesla share price…
Enjoyed this newsletter? Get Involved.
- Subscribe to MacroMashup: one email a week, zero noise.
- Book a call with Dakota Ridge Capital if you’re investing in clean energy or want to optimize for tax strategy
- Watch us on YouTube, or tune in via Spotify / Apple
- Collaborate with us at contact@macromashup.com