HomeRight AerrowInsightsSepratorMacroMashupSeparator
Swipe Left on Market Narratives: Why Investors Need to Stay Nimble
MacroMashup Newsletter

Swipe Left on Market Narratives: Why Investors Need to Stay Nimble

Know who is selling you what

Apr 25, 2025
Neil Winward

Author:

Neil Winward

|

Founder and CEO

of

Dakota Ridge Capital

Book a free energy consultation

here
    Swipe Left on Market Narratives: Why Investors Need to Stay Nimble
    Get our weekly MacroMashup newsletters.
    Thank you! Your submission has been received!
    Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

    Welcome to Macro Mashup, the weekly newsletter that distills the content from key voices on macroeconomics, geopolitics, and energy in less than 7 minutes. Thank you for subscribing!

    Macro Mashup aims to bring together the greatest minds in Finance and Economics who care deeply about current U.S. and international affairs. We study the latest news and laws that affect our economy, money, and lives, so you don't have to.

    Tune in to our channels and join our newsletter, podcast, or community to stay informed so you can make smarter decisions to protect your wealth.

    Markets moved 2,000 points this week. Here’s why that doesn’t mean what you think—and what to do about it.

    This Week’s Markets: A Love-Hate Relationship with the Narrative

    Investors saw the full emotional spectrum play out this week.

    On Monday, markets plunged. By Wednesday, they soared. On Thursday, they steadied. The trigger? Headlines, not fundamentals.

    President Trump called Fed Chair Jerome Powell a “loser” and “Mr. Too Late.” The Dow dropped 970 points. Gold hit new highs. Safe havens surged. Then, within 48 hours, Trump changed his tone: Powell’s job was safe. China trade talks were “nice.” Tariffs might be coming down. Markets rallied hard. Gold sold off.

    If this feels like whiplash, it’s because it is. And it’s not new..

    Narratives Don’t Lead—They Follow

    Here’s the thing: markets don’t marry narratives. Neither should you.

    Each week, there’s a new storyline:

    • Sell America—dump bonds, stocks, the dollar.
    • Buy gold—it’s a hedge against the end of the world.
    • Trump is torching global alliances.
    • Tariffs are freezing supply chains.

    Sometimes these are true. Sometimes they’re noise. Always, they’re fleeting.

    Markets digest narratives like memes—they go viral, then fade. Being early to abandon a narrative is often more profitable than sticking around for its downfall.

    What Just Happened (And What Didn’t)

    Let’s look at this week in numbers:

    • Monday:
      • Dow down ~970 pts
      • S&P 500 down ~2.4%
      • Nasdaq down ~2.6%
      • USD drops to 3-year low
      • Gold spikes to an all-time-high
    • Tuesday:
      • Dow +1,000 pts
      • S&P and Nasdaq rebound nearly 3%
      • Treasury hints at a China trade thaw
    • Wednesday:
      • Trump reassures: Fed Chair stays, tariffs may fall
      • Gold sells off ~3%
      • Silver rallies sharply
    • Thursday:
      • Stocks rallied for a third day in a row—the last time that happened was March 26th
      • Silver eased a little, and gold continued up
      • Credit spreads narrowed
      • Overall, Trump mainly focused on foreign policy and left the markets alone

    This isn’t about fundamentals. It’s narrative whiplash. And it’s dominating the price action.

    Gold Retreats. Silver Rises. Here’s Why.

    As equities crumbled, gold absorbed the fear. But once the narrative turned, so did capital flows. Investors hiding out in gold used the rally to take profits and, when stocks rebounded, used those profits to buy equities.

    Silver, often the neglected sibling, is getting more attention:

    • Half its value is tied to industrial demand
    • A tariff rollback would increase demand
    • Silver remains historically undervalued vs. gold

    Silver’s smaller market cap also means it reacts faster to shifts in supply and demand.

    Wall Street Isn’t Buying It

    Since April 8, the bond market has been challenging the Trump narrative. And now, Wall Street is retaking the reins.

    Yes, the President can tweet. But the Fed sets policy. And the market is watching Powell, not the press briefings.

    Why Are Markets Fighting Back?

    1. Policy Uncertainty – Businesses can’t plan. Markets can’t price.
    2. Fed Independence – If you aim at Powell, don’t miss.
    3. Volatility Surge – Spiking VIX = investor doubt.
    4. Capital Rotation – Money is flowing fast—winners are temporary.

    Trump vs. Powell: Act II

    This isn’t the first round.

    • December 2018: Powell hikes. Trump lashes out. Market drops.
    • 2019: Fed cuts four times. S&P ends up +29%.
    • March 2020: Pandemic panic (-34%), then Fed stimulus. S&P up +18%.

    Each time, the narrative flipped. Each time, the market moved before the story played out.

    Investing in a Post-Narrative World

    Want to survive? Here’s your playbook:

    • Stay flexible – Agility > conviction
    • Favor data over drama – Narrative is noise
    • Diversify – Don’t anchor to one asset class
    • Buy panic, sell hype – Contrarian wins
    • History is helpful, not predictive – Rhymes, not repeats
    • Find a source you trust and stick to it—I recommend one below.

    In The Markets—Chart to Watch

    The S&P 500 bottomed near ~4,985—a rare three-standard-deviation move. Technicians are now watching the “death cross”: when the 50-day MA slips below the 200-day MA.

    It could mean more downside. Or it could be the beginning of a reversal. Either way, use rallies to trim risk and rebalance.

    Bottom Line

    Don’t fall in love with the narrative. Swipe left when the story stops serving you.

    Markets aren’t loyal to one version of reality, and neither should your portfolio.

    What’s Next/What To Follow

    For those looking for a great perspective on the macro picture and a very reasonably priced framework for structuring their investments, Darius Dale is the man. I subscribe to his service and follow his KISS framework. The Value/Price relationship is outstanding.

    If you want to get some great insights into the whole macro spectrum—including Bitcoin—there is no better place to go than this brilliant conversation between Natalie Brunell and Lyn Alden.

    Enjoyed this newsletter? Get Involved.

    Subscribe to MacroMashup for market breakdowns like this, straight to your inbox—without the noise.

    1. If you want to get involved in clean energy and take advantage of the generous tax credits the government offers, book a complimentary call with my advisory firm, Dakota Ridge Capital here
    2. Do you prefer video? You can now watch MacroMashup on our YouTube channel - or, if audio is your preference, tune in on Spotify or Apple
    3. We are always open to collaborations, whether clean energy or macroeconomics. Just send an email to contact@macromashup.com
    4. If you enjoy this newsletter, share it on X here, or email it to a friend by clicking on the button below.
    Help others learn, click to share
      Neil Winward

      Neil Winward is the founding partner of Dakota Ridge Captial, helping investors, developers, banks, non-profits, and family offices unlock massive tax savings - on average of 7%- 10% - via clean energy investments by fully leveraging U.S. government incentives such the Inflation Reduction Act.

      BOOK A CALL

      READY TO TAKE ACTION ON YOUR ENERGY PROJECT? BOOK A COMPLIMENTARY, ZERO-OBLIGATION CONSULTATION TO SEE HOW WE CAN HELP YOU.

      Book Here
      vectorvector
      From Kyiv to Jackson Hole: How Deal-Making and Fed Policy Are Reshaping Markets
      MacroMashup Newsletter
      3

      From Kyiv to Jackson Hole: How Deal-Making and Fed Policy Are Reshaping Markets

      Neil Winward

      From Kyiv to semiconductors, Washington is turning leverage into deals.

      Kyiv’s $150B Framework — Europe Pays, America Sells

      Ukraine is floating a $150B package: $90–100B in U.S. weapons financed largely by European partners, plus $50B in joint drone production with American firms. The aim: secure U.S. guarantees, tie Europe to long-term financing, and lock in U.S. industrial participation post-accord.
      Investor read-through: Whether war drags on or peace takes hold, U.S. defense revenues are baked in.

      Chips as Cash Register and Cudgel

      Washington is weighing converting CHIPS Act (Biden-era legislation) subsidies into ~10% non-voting equity in Intel, while demanding a 15% skim on Nvidia’s China H20 revenues (with AMD reportedly in the mix). Subsidies become stakes; export licenses become toll booths.
      Market angle: Intel cuts funding costs, its CEO gets out of Trump PR-jail, but the company inherits policy overhang. Nvidia preserves access to China at thinner margins, creating a precedent for license-conditioned economics.

      Resetting Bargaining Power

      Intel’s CEO drew rare public rebuke before reports of a U.S. stake surfaced. The sequence signals Washington’s tactic: first apply pressure, then attach capital and concessions. A similar logic shapes Ukraine—float peace terms, attach U.S. guarantees to industrial deals, shift financing burdens to Europe. After a disastrous first meeting at the White House, Zelensky learned the ropes: wear a suit (Trump asked nicely), and offer candy to the President.

      Risk Map — Policy Volatility Premium

      • Ukraine: Proposals touching Crimea or NATO renunciation collide with Kyiv’s constitution, sustaining demand for drones and air defense near term. Russia continues to pound Ukraine; Trump shakes his head, and Europe borrows at scale to fully re-arm.
      • Policy volatility: Equity stakes, skims, and tariff threats can shift overnight. Watch CHIPS disbursement calendars and export-license reviews. This flatters China’s Made in China 2025 plan.
      • Industrial crowding: Winners get capital and contracts; laggards face higher costs of capital and tighter scrutiny.

      From Solyndra to Skims — The Policy Evolution

      • Then (2011): Solyndra’s $535M DOE loan guarantee left taxpayers exposed to full downside with no upside levers. Bankruptcy cemented its infamy.
      • Now (2025): Equity stakes, royalties, and conditional licenses tie support to performance. Taxpayers gain contingent upside, policymakers retain control.

      Continuity: Public capital still steers industry.
      Discontinuity: The model shifted from “guarantee the bet” to “own the option and meter the gate.”

      Powell’s Jackson Hole Balancing Act

      Navigating market sentiment, skewed toward a September rate cut, and his own focus on a legacy of not being Arthur Burns, Powell made the tightrope look like a suspension bridge and the markets cheered him all the way across.

      Key Takeaways:

      • He rationalized the tension in the data—CPI, PPI, and employment—with a classic bit of central banker-speak: “Distinguishing cyclical from trend is difficult.” Translation: reasonable folks can differ; the data can be confusing.
      • He acknowledged the one-time price shock of tariffs. Yes, there’s uncertainty. Yes, impact is accumulating unevenly. But it’s “manageable,” and unless the labor market tightens, a wage-price spiral seems unlikely.
      • GDP is slowing. Powell admits policy may be too restrictive.
      • The neutral Fed Funds rate may be higher than we thought, but the time may be right to finally adjust policy.

      But before we sign off on the full “Chairman Redemption” narrative, let’s check the history:

      1. Tightened too much in Q4 2018—then promptly U-turned.
      2. Eased too slowly in Q1 2020—late to the punch, pandemic edition.
      3. Tightened too late in 2021-2022—no one forgets “transitory.”
      4. Failed to adequately supervise in the lead-up to the regional banking crisis of 2023—“nobody saw it coming,” except, of course, the chart watchers.

      Powell can’t pull legacy from the jaws of mediocrity just by #resisting Trump. But, he has baked in a cut for September.

      How did the markets take it? Powell just lit a rocket:

      • Stocks: bid
      • Bonds: bid
      • Precious metals: bid
      • Bitcoin: bid
      • USD: sell

      Whatever the Fed’s gameplan, risk assets loved the vibe—at least for today. See asset table below for the play-by-play.

      In The Markets — AI Rally Meets Reality

      The AI trade hit turbulence. Earnings reality is replacing hype as capital rotates into balance-sheet strength and defensives. Regulators are tightening rhetoric on AI ethics. This week feels less like panic, more like a collective exhale — conviction over FOMO. And, to make a happy Friday, Powell took his foot off the brake—watch the markets burn some rubber.

      Closing Thoughts

      The only thing running harder than the market since April might be the collective imagination of AI boosters—until Sam Altman’s “pause” and Meta’s hiring freeze called time, and the markets paused. 

      Enter Powell, just in time to stop the slide. But in Jackson Hole or on Wall Street, remember: the 12 Fed governors are just hikers, navigating terrain the Teton-sized terrain of broader financial markets. They should hand the short-term rate decisions to the markets, but, for now, Powell has avoided a fifth policy mistake and kept the shadow of Arthur Burns at bay. 

      Enjoyed this newsletter? Get Involved.

      • Subscribe to MacroMashup: one email a week, zero noise.
      • Book a call with Dakota Ridge Capital if you’re investing in clean energy or want to optimize for tax strategy
      • Watch us on YouTube, or tune in via Spotify / Apple
      • Collaborate with us at contact@macromashup.com

      📤 Enjoyed this? Share it via LinkedIn, repost on X → here, or forward it via email.

      Read More
      From Tariffs to Bitcoin: How 2025 Markets Keep Defying the Risks
      MacroMashup Newsletter
      3

      From Tariffs to Bitcoin: How 2025 Markets Keep Defying the Risks

      Neil Winward

      Gold spikes. Data gets political. Deficits swell.

      Markets are scaling a wall of worry built from tariffs, politicized data, swelling deficits, and attacks on the Fed. Behind the noise, liquidity flows are dictating asset prices — rewarding investors who hedge, diversify, and stay nimble.

      Gold Tariff Whiplash

      Close-up of stacked 1000g gold bars on a financial trading chart with red and green candlestick patterns.

      President Trump jolted metals markets with a post floating a 39% tariff on Swiss gold bars. Spot gold spiked above $3,500/oz in a record rally; central banks bought ~120 tons in a week; hedge funds scrambled. Days later, Trump reversed course, sparking a partial pullback but leaving volatility elevated.
      Investor takeaway: Policy-by-tweet can reprice global assets in hours. Portfolios need allocations to policy hedges — gold, TIPS, commodity producers, and increasingly, Bitcoin.

      BLS Under Scrutiny

      Press conference with speaker at podium in front of large financial chart, audience seated, and multiple U.S. flags on stage.
    • July CPI: +0.2% m/m, +2.7% y/y; core CPI at 3.1% vs. 3.0% consensus.
    • Energy costs fell; shelter remained stable.
    • New BLS chief raising concerns about politicized statistics.
    • July PPI: +0.9% m/m;
      • Services costs: +1.1%
      • Goods ex-food & energy: +0.4% — largest jump in three years.
    • Traders now hedge data credibility as well as the numbers themselves — potentially reshaping Fed policy expectations.
    • Markets pricing in a 25–50bps rate cut; 84% probability of a cut.
    • Question remains: Will Jay Powell push back on markets using PPI, core CPI, and retail sales trends as ammunition?
    • Tariffs vs. Deficits

      Split-screen image showing piles of U.S. dollar bills in front of stone columns on the left, and a red downward-trending stock market chart on the right.

      Tariff revenues hit a record $28B in July, on pace for $300B annually. But with a $291B monthly deficit (+10% YoY), Medicare, Social Security, and interest costs overwhelm gains. Less than 10% of federal revenue comes from tariffs, and corporate tax cuts offset half the inflows. Markets are largely pricing out tariff volatility — at least for now.

      Pressure on the Fed

      he Federal Reserve building in Washington, D.C., illuminated at dusk with two statues in the foreground and a dramatic, colorful sky overhead.

      Populist rhetoric about taking control of rate-setting — or abolishing the Fed — is gaining traction at the political fringes. While a shutdown is unlikely, political harassment could lift term premiums, dent reserve currency trust, and inject volatility into FOMC events. Read our related article here

      Equities at Records

      Wall Street traders on the stock exchange floor cheering and raising their hands as market screens display strong gains.

      The S&P 500 and Nasdaq 100 have logged 15 all-time highs in 2025. Nearly 80% of S&P firms posted record profits, but gains are concentrated in tech, semis, and mega-caps. Small caps and cyclicals lag. The result: shallow pullbacks, a steady grind higher, and FOMO-driven capital rotation.

      Bitcoin Treasuries Go Mainstream

      Corporate boardroom table covered with stacks of gold coins, business charts scattered across the surface, and a businessman standing in front of a financial graph on a large screen.

      More companies are raising capital to buy and hold Bitcoin, often trading above their BTC net asset value. GAAP accounting allows paper gains to flow into earnings. Strategy ($MSTR) holds >214,000 BTC; roughly 160 public/private firms hold ~4% of total supply. The thesis: hedge against fiat risk and maintain liquidity outside traditional banks.

      Summer 2025 Playbook

      Shiny gold bars connected by glowing digital network lines, symbolizing the intersection of precious metals and blockchain technology.

      Policy volatility, fiscal strain, politicized data, and concentrated market leadership define the current climb. The winners are those with:

      • Exposure to both real and digital assets
      • Agile rebalancing strategies
      • Hedges in place before shocks hit

      In The Markets 

      Closing Thoughts

      Fragility is structural. Adaptability is alpha. In 2025, the wall of worry isn’t a metaphor — it’s the market’s foundation.

      Enjoyed this newsletter? Get Involved.

      Read More
      Macro Fragility, AI Frontiers & the Robo-Industrial Revolution
      MacroMashup Newsletter
      3

      Macro Fragility, AI Frontiers & the Robo-Industrial Revolution

      Neil Winward

      What Top Market Voices Are Saying—Where They Agree, Where They Don’t

      Markets, macro, and machines: as the world drifts through a confusing summer, we check in on the key debates dividing leading economists, strategists, and futurists.

      The Macro Wall of Worry

      Tight Windows, Fragile Liquidity

      Markets entered August walking a tightrope of optimism and anxiety. July’s “resilience narrative” has given way to the familiar late-cycle brew: seasonal weakness, sticky inflation, and an undercurrent of fragile liquidity.

      • Tight Liquidity: The Fed’s hold on rate cuts—even as growth slows—has drained the punch bowl. Reserves are shrinking. A $9.4T debt rollover looms. Short-term debt (T-bills) will dominate issuance as Treasury positions for a future rate-driven shift in the curve.
      • Market Plumbing: Forget vibes. Liquidity plumbing—not sentiment—is steering this market.
      • Risk Assets at Extremes: Forward P/Es on the S&P flirt with unsustainable highs, eerily reminiscent of pre-tightening peaks.
      • Policy Paralysis: The Fed is boxed in—caught between fiscal excess and inflation’s refusal to fade.
      • Seasonal Setup: August–September is historically weak for the S&P. Add a softening labor market, deteriorating credit, ISM contraction (32 months and counting), and tariff volatility, and it’s a perfect storm.

      Bottom Line: Stay agile. Monitor liquidity metrics closely—especially the $2.3T Fed reserve threshold (banks’ reserve buffer at the Fed to keep interbank payments running smoothly). That’s your rally signal. But until then, don’t front-run hope.

      Institutional Shocks

      NFP Misses, BLS Shake-Up, and Fed Fallout

      Credibility risk is rising across institutions.

      • Weak Jobs Report: NFP data fell short, shaking the market’s confidence. Conditions eerily mirror Fall 2024: cooling inflation, slowing growth, and a labor market under pressure.
      • The Fed claims the labor market’s fine, so no cut. But Treasury and markets see stress building fast—and warn inaction now means damage control later
      • Political Intrusion: President Trump’s removal of the BLS commissioner after the data “errors” raised alarms about politicizing statistics.
      • Fed Turmoil: A key Fed governor’s abrupt resignation added fuel to concerns about central bank independence and internal division.

      Market Implication: When the arbiters of truth wobble, so does investor confidence. Volatility rises not from data alone—but from distrust in those delivering it. Hot take: Let the market set rates—why should 12 unelected officials (5 voting) dictate the cost of capital across trillions in collateral? Market pricing would settle the Fed independence debate once and for all.

      Consensus & Contention

      Where Macro Heavyweights Converge (and Clash)

      Top 10 Points of Agreement:

      1. Liquidity rules everything.
      2. We are in a late-cycle environment.
      3. Policy tools are almost spent.
      4. Debt levels are structurally dangerous.
      5. Volatility windows are cyclical—and tradable.
      6. The dollar is a directional fulcrum.
      7. Tightening impacts are just now showing (lag effect).
      8. Structural themes (AI, deglobalization) matter.
      9. Adaptive portfolios outperform (asset allocation matters).
      10. Macro liquidity cycles repeat. Always.

      5 Key Points of Disagreement:

      1. Inflation’s trajectory—entrenched or transitory?
      2. What drives the next regime: QE or fiscal expansion?
      3. Crash magnitude—apocalypse or a healthy pullback?
      4. China’s slowdown—threat or manageable friction?
      5. AI as a supercycle—or speculative bubble?

      Takeaway: Don’t follow consensus—exploit its blind spots. Where everyone agrees, risk often hides. Asset allocation, not stock picking, is key.

      The Age of Context: AI’s Next Supercycle?

      Remi Teton, aka “The Mad King,” lays out a compelling framework for what’s next in AI.

      Highlights:

      1. From Taskbots to Context Engines: AI is evolving into memory-driven systems that understand time, identity, and environment.
      2. The Context Stack: Massive infrastructure buildout required—GPUs, storage, data lakes, identity and governance systems.
      3. Retail AI Revolution: Real-time analytics are no longer just for quants.
      4. Ethical Whiplash: Narrow, biased data leads to dangerous blind spots. EU-style regulation is coming for AI.
      5. Volatility Risks: Retail AI adoption could fuel flash crashes if herd behavior outpaces oversight.
      6. Robo-Humans in the Workforce: Apptronik’s Apollo and others are making robots practical—not to replace labor, but to augment it.
      7. Industrial Rethink: Deglobalization and aging demographics push robots to the factory floor—and logistics centers.
      8. Winners & Losers: The winners won’t be vaporware demos, but real-world deployments that deliver ROI and pass regulatory scrutiny.

      Actionable Signals

      • Watch Fed reserves: Below $2.3T is a red flag.
      • Monitor Treasury auctions: Stress = fragility. Pay attention to refinancing maturities.
      • Defensive positioning: August–September often punishes the complacent.
      • Watch boring AI: Governance, compliance, and infrastructure names may outperform flashy narratives.
      • Asset allocation—stocks, precious metals, Bitcoin—is your superpower, not stock picking.

      In The Markets

      Closing Thought

      The 2020s aren’t the FANG decade. This is the context decade. Macro fragility meets exponential tech—and those betting on infrastructure and watching signals, not just narrative, will win.

      Stay adaptive. Stay skeptical. Stay fearless

      Enjoyed this newsletter? Get Involved.

      Read More
      IRA Broacher
      IRA Report To Smarter Investing
      Unlock the Opportunities of the Inflation Reduction Act!​ Are you ready to stay ahead in today's shifting economic landscape? Our comprehensive white paper breaks down the Inflation Reduction Act and reveals the key benefits, incentives, and strategies your business needs to capitalize on. Learn how to optimize your financial planning, leverage tax credits, and position your company for sustainable growth.
      Pre-order now to get the insights and actionable steps that can give your business a competitive edge.
      New Version Release Date: 12/10/2024
      Thank you! Your submission has been received!
      Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
      Close icon