HomeRight AerrowInsightsSepratorMacroMashupSeparator
The Real Challenge in Climate Isn’t Carbon. It’s Capital
MacroMashup Newsletter

The Real Challenge in Climate Isn’t Carbon. It’s Capital

Clean energy wins when the math works—and the math is finally working.

Nov 5, 2025
Neil Winward

Author:

Neil Winward

|

Founder and CEO

of

Dakota Ridge Capital

Book a free energy consultation

here
    The Real Challenge in Climate Isn’t Carbon. It’s Capital
    Get our weekly MacroMashup newsletters.
    Thank you! Your submission has been received!
    Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

    Bill Gates Is Right About Climate—But Here’s the Part Most People Miss

    Bill Gates recently published an essay called “Three Tough Truths About Climate.”

    It’s one of the rare climate pieces that is both data-driven and realistic, without the panic theater.

    The central point is simple:

    Climate change will not lead to human extinction.

    But lifting billions of people out of poverty while decarbonizing the world will be the biggest infrastructure buildout in human history.

    That is the real challenge—not the headlines, not the doomsday narratives, and not the political shouting.

    Climate is a scaling problem, and scaling requires capital, technology, and policy that makes clean energy bankable.

    Let’s break down Gates’ argument—and the piece everyone forgets to talk about.

    The world needs more energy, not less

    This is the truth almost nobody says out loud.

    • Global energy demand will more than double by 2050
    • Economic growth depends on electricity
    • The fastest way to reduce climate vulnerability is to make countries wealthier

    Gates puts it bluntly:

    “You can’t reduce emissions by keeping people poor.”

    If the goal is human welfare—not just carbon accounting—we need cheap, reliable, abundant power.

    That means:

    • Massive grid buildouts
    • Energy storage at scale
    • Distributed systems for the poorest regions
    • Manufacturing powered by clean energy, not coal

    You don’t get there by shrinking the energy supply.

    You get there by rebuilding it.

    The good news: technology is winning

    This part isn’t widely known outside of energy circles:

    • Solar and wind prices have dropped 90% in two decades
    • Storage is falling fast
    • In many regions, clean energy is the cheapest electricity on Earth

    Gates notes that in the past 10 years, projected global CO₂ emissions for 2040 have dropped over 40% due to innovation. That progress happened quietly and without enough credit.

    The climate story is no longer “renewables are too expensive.”

    The story is now:

    renewables scale fastest when the financing structure is bankable.

    That’s where policy and project finance matter.

    The bottleneck is no longer technology

    It’s capital, transmission, and bankable deals

    Breakthroughs exist:

    • Zero-emission steel
    • Clean cement
    • Green hydrogen
    • Low-carbon fertilizers
    • Methane-reducing livestock feed
    • Advanced nuclear
    • Industrial heat pumps

    But innovation without financing is just a lab result.

    Projects do not move without:

    ✅ predictable revenue

    ✅ risk mitigation

    ✅ creditworthy counterparties

    ✅ standardized contracts

    ✅ tax incentives that pencil for investors

    This is why U.S. tax-credit policy changed everything.

    By allowing transferability, credits became a real financial asset class—not just a tax-technical tool for large corporates.

    In many cases, this reduced the cost of capital and accelerated adoption.

    The hardest part ahead: scaling to poor countries

    Climate risk is not evenly distributed.

    Rich nations can adapt.

    Poor nations suffer most.

    But here’s the uncomfortable reality:

    If a nation cannot afford electricity, climate spending is irrelevant.

    To protect lives:

    • Energy must be cheap
    • Systems must be reliable
    • Financing must be accessible
    • Risk must be insurable

    A good climate strategy is also a good development strategy.

    Clean energy is not a luxury product—it’s critical infrastructure.

    Stop measuring success only in carbon

    This is where Gates is exactly right.

    If every climate conversation ends at “X tons of CO₂ avoided,” we’ve missed the point.

    The real metric is:

    • How many lives improved?
    • How many communities electrified?
    • How many people protected from heat waves, crop loss, and instability?
    • How many nations gained energy independence?

    Human welfare is the North Star.

    Carbon is just one variable.

    The takeaway: we don’t need fear

    We need scale

    Climate change is not an extinction scenario.

    It’s a buildout scenario.

    We will need:

    • Gigawatts of new generation
    • Terawatt-hours of storage
    • Steel, copper, transmission lines
    • Billions in capital
    • Insurance, indemnities, and offtake contracts
    • And a financing system that makes it profitable to build

    When clean energy makes financial sense, it scales.

    When it scales, people thrive.

    That’s the future worth betting on.

    Closing

    Gates is right to remind the world that this isn’t about apocalyptic doom.

    It’s about engineering, economics, and global development.

    The world doesn’t need less energy.

    It needs more energy—clean, abundant, reliable—and accessible to every nation.

    If we measure success by human welfare, we will solve climate faster than fear ever could.

    Enjoyed this newsletter? Get Involved.

    • Subscribe to MacroMashup: one email a week, zero noise.
    • Book a call with Dakota Ridge Capital if you’re investing in clean energy or want to optimize for tax strategy
    • Watch us on YouTube, or tune in via Spotify / Apple
    • Collaborate with us at contact@macromashup.com

    📤 Enjoyed this? Share it via LinkedIn, repost on X → here, or forward it via email.

    Help others learn, click to share
      Neil Winward

      Neil Winward is the founding partner of Dakota Ridge Captial, helping investors, developers, banks, non-profits, and family offices unlock massive tax savings - on average of 7%- 10% - via clean energy investments by fully leveraging U.S. government incentives such the Inflation Reduction Act.

      BOOK A CALL

      READY TO TAKE ACTION ON YOUR ENERGY PROJECT? BOOK A COMPLIMENTARY, ZERO-OBLIGATION CONSULTATION TO SEE HOW WE CAN HELP YOU.

      Book Here
      vectorvector
      MacroMashup— Annual 2025 Macro Brief
      MacroMashup Newsletter
      3

      MacroMashup— Annual 2025 Macro Brief

      Neil Winward

      2025 wasn’t defined by chaos, but by clarification. This Annual Macro Brief explains which assumptions quietly expired, what markets now price first, and how investors should enter 2026 oriented — not reactive.

      Welcome to MacroMashup—your weekly briefing on the real forces driving markets beneath the headlines. If you want disciplined macro analysis, portfolio frameworks, and real-world capital insights, subscribe to receive every deep dive.

      2025 was the year the macro narrative stopped being theoretical and started reshaping portfolios.

      Energy constraints became investment realities. AI’s infrastructure demands materialized. Geopolitical fragmentation stopped being a tail risk and became a structural feature. And the Federal Reserve’s familiar playbook proved far less effective than many expected.

      But the most important development of 2025 wasn’t a single call or market move.

      It was a shift in how markets respond.

      Markets became less responsive to forecasts, guidance, and clean narratives — and more responsive to capacity, constraints, and balance-sheet realities. Investors who adjusted their mental models early felt calmer by year-end. Those who didn’t often felt increasingly reactive, even as information became more abundant.

      This Annual Macro Brief is not a prediction for 2026.

      It’s a reset.

      It lays out what 2025 clarified, which assumptions quietly expired, and how investors should approach the year ahead with stronger orientation, better decision discipline, and fewer narrative-driven mistakes.

      Why 2025 Was a Clarifying Year (Not a Volatile One)

      Many investors will remember 2025 as noisy.

      Rates moved. Markets chopped. Narratives rotated quickly. At times, it felt like nothing stuck long enough to trust.

      That interpretation misses the point.

      2025 wasn’t defined by instability. It was defined by disillusionment — the quiet removal of assumptions investors had been carrying forward from the prior decade.

      Markets didn’t behave irrationally. They behaved selectively.

      Some signals stopped working.

      Some reassurance stopped landing.

      Some explanations stopped producing follow-through.

      What felt confusing was actually a sorting process.

      Markets were clarifying what still matters, what matters less, and what no longer works at all.

      What 2025 Made Clear (That Markets Now Price)

      The most important lesson of 2025 wasn’t about growth or inflation levels.

      It was about responsiveness.

      Markets became less responsive to:

      • Policy signaling
      • Forward guidance
      • Consensus optimism
      • Clean narratives

      And more responsive to:

      • Capacity
      • Constraints
      • Balance-sheet realities
      • Physical and political limits

      This explains why “good news” often failed to extend rallies — and why “bad news” sometimes barely moved prices.

      Three clarifications stood out.

      First, inflation behavior mattered more than inflation prints.

      Markets stopped reacting to month-to-month fluctuations and focused instead on persistence, stickiness, and second-order effects.

      Second, policy intent mattered less than policy capacity.

      What central banks wanted to do mattered less than what they could do without triggering unintended consequences.

      Third, liquidity mattered more than narratives.

      When liquidity tightened, markets became less forgiving regardless of the story attached to it.

      Assets closer to the edge of the ‘circulatory system’—Bitcoin—suffered most.

      None of this happened suddenly. Markets priced it quietly.

      What 2025 Quietly Removed From the Investor Playbook

      Some assumptions didn’t weaken in 2025. They expired.

      One was the belief that liquidity backstops are automatic. Intervention now comes with trade-offs, delays, and political constraints.

      Another was the idea that diversification always reduces risk. Correlations rose when it mattered most, and complexity often hid fragility rather than reducing it.

      Perhaps most importantly, 2025 challenged the belief that waiting for clarity is a viable strategy. By the time clarity arrived, markets had often already moved.

      These removals created discomfort — because they didn’t come with immediate replacements.

      But those gaps also created opportunity for investors willing to update their frameworks.

      The Five Dominant Macro Themes of 2025

      1. The AI Energy Imperative: Power Became the Bottleneck

      AI’s computational demands turned energy infrastructure into critical investment terrain. The winners weren’t just software companies — they were those controlling power generation, transmission, and reliability.

      2025 takeaway: Energy stocks outperformed tech late in the year. Companies solving AI’s power problem gained pricing power.

      2026 implication: The AI trade is now an energy trade.

      2. The Death of the “Work” Metric

      Traditional labor statistics broke down. Work continued. Productivity surged. Jobs disappeared from official measures.

      Markets stopped reacting to employment prints and focused instead on margins, productivity, and automation.

      2026 implication: Watch productivity, profit margins, and capex — not headline employment data.

      3. The Commodity Reset

      Commodities stopped acting like cyclical hedges and started behaving like structural growth assets.

      Gold and silver reflected monetary debasement and central bank diversification. Copper, uranium, and critical minerals became national security issues.

      2026 implication: Commodities belong in portfolios as growth positions, not just protection.

      4. Geopolitical Fragmentation Accelerated

      The post–Cold War order continued to unwind. Globalization gave way to regionalization. Supply-chain sovereignty became policy priority.

      2026 implication: Favor regional resilience over global efficiency.

      5. The K-Shaped Reality Deepened

      Asset owners continued to win. Labor lagged. Scarce assets outperformed. Broad averages masked widening dispersion.

      2026 implication: Quality, scarcity, and conviction matter more than broad exposure.

      A Shift in How We Think About 2026

      Before laying out actions, it’s worth addressing something directly.

      The biggest upgrade heading into 2026 isn’t a new theme — it’s a new level of rigor in decision-making.

      2025 reminded us of a simple truth: good outcomes don’t always mean good decisions, and bad outcomes don’t always mean bad ones.

      That distinction matters.

      Inspired by the principles outlined in Thinking in Bets (Annie Dukes), MacroMashup is placing greater emphasis on:

      • Decision quality over outcome chasing
      • Explicit recognition of uncertainty
      • Bias awareness and probabilistic thinking
      • Reviewing calls with discipline, not ego

      The goal isn’t to sound more cautious. It’s to be more accountable.

      That shift — toward clearer frameworks, stress-tested assumptions, and shared learning — is the foundation of what’s coming in 2026.

      The Constraints That Define 2026

      Entering 2026, markets are anchored to constraints that move slowly and matter deeply:

      • Energy capacity remains a physical reality
      • Debt and fiscal flexibility limit policy choices
      • Labor and demographics cap growth potential
      • Geopolitical fragmentation increases friction
      • The cost of capital is no longer negligible

      These aren’t forecasts. They’re boundaries.

      Markets don’t debate them. They work around them.

      2026 Action Plan: Five Moves for the Year Ahead

      1. Build Energy Infrastructure Exposure

      Natural gas midstream, nuclear, grid modernization, and AI-adjacent power infrastructure.

      Why: AI’s energy demands are non-negotiable.

      How: ~15–20% of growth allocation.

      2. Increase Commodity Exposure Structurally

      Gold, copper, uranium, and critical materials.

      Why: Structural demand meets constrained supply.

      How: Favor physical exposure and quality producers.

      3. Focus on AI’s Second-Order Beneficiaries

      Not Nvidia — but the companies serving Nvidia’s customers.

      Why: Second-order effects are less crowded.

      How: Automation, infrastructure, and productivity enablers.

      4. Embrace the K-Shaped Reality

      Scarce assets over broad exposure.

      Why: Dispersion persists.

      How: Concentration in highest-conviction positions.

      5. Prepare for Shocks — Don’t Trade Them

      Volatility will rise. Structural trends remain.

      Why: Headlines exaggerate noise.

      How: Maintain dry powder. Execute the plan.

      What to Stop Doing in 2026

      • Stop trading Fed announcements
      • Stop chasing “cheap” value without structural support
      • Stop diversifying for comfort rather than resilience
      • Stop waiting for “normal” to return

      Volatility is the baseline.

      Macro Mashup: Deep-Dive Insights, Weekly

      Macro Mashup is where we go deeper, every week.

      It’s a weekly deep dive into the forces shaping markets right now — macroeconomics, energy, geopolitics, capital flows, and policy — with an emphasis on what actually matters versus what simply dominates headlines.

      Subscribers receive:

      • Weekly deep-dive analysis
      • Clear frameworks to interpret current events
      • Context that helps you avoid narrative-driven decisions

      If you want to start the year oriented instead of reactive, this is the best place to begin.

      macromashup.com

      Already Reading Macro Mashup? Explore Fearless Investor

      If you’re already subscribed to Macro Mashup, our sister publication, Fearless Investor, takes a complementary approach.

      Fearless Investor focuses on:

      • Portfolio strategy and allocation
      • Behavioral finance and decision-making
      • Practical systems and tools for DIY investors

      It’s less about what’s happening out there — and more about how to structure decisions and portfolios in response.

      Many readers follow both because together they cover:

      • Macro context (Macro Mashup)
      • Investor behavior, strategy, and systems (Fearless Investor)

      If you haven’t explored Fearless Investor yet, it’s worth a look.

      Continue reading here →

      https://open.substack.com/pub/fearlessinvestor

      Final Thought

      2025 clarified something essential:

      The old rules didn’t break overnight — they stopped compounding.

      Energy determines AI winners.

      Commodities determine energy winners.

      Geopolitics determines access.

      Automation determines survival.

      The through-line is scarcity.

      Your 2026 portfolio shouldn’t answer what you think will happen next.

      It should answer what becomes more valuable as the world fragments, electrifies, and automates.

      That’s where durable returns come from.

      Get Involved

      MacroMashup paid members receive full weekly deep dives, portfolio frameworks, and early access to investor-grade analysis. If you want to understand how liquidity, policy, and capital structure actually shape returns, subscribe today. 

      macromashup.com 

      Already subscribed? Enjoy this week’s deep dive!

      Read More
      Markets Adjust to Policy Drift as Powell’s Successor Nears
      MacroMashup Newsletter
      3

      Markets Adjust to Policy Drift as Powell’s Successor Nears

      Metals outperform, bitcoin cools, and custom silicon reshapes tech leadership amid policy uncertainty

      The Calm Is Misleading

      Welcome to MacroMashup—your weekly briefing on the real forces driving markets beneath the headlines. If you want disciplined macro analysis, portfolio frameworks, and real-world capital insights, subscribe to receive every deep dive.

      Markets spent the week projecting stability. Equity volatility stayed contained. Credit spreads barely moved. Headlines focused on jobs data, health-care politics, and another round of AI bubble arguments.

      But beneath the surface, the system is under stress.

      Pressure on Maduro just jumped a notch: Trump has ordered a blockade of sanctioned oil tankers in and out of Venezuela while Europe tightens its own sanctions, choking off Caracas’s hard‑currency lifeline and raising the odds of a messy regime crack rather than a choreographed transition. That would be a gift to neighboring economies, and local rates would likely keep grinding lower as risk premia compress.​

      In Washington, Congress appears ready to leave town without extending enhanced ACA subsidies, setting up a politically manufactured premium shock for millions of households in 2026.

      The Fed, for its part, managed to get its labor-market story wrong in under a week: the glide path to 4.5% unemployment sketched at the last meeting has already been mugged by a 4.6% unemployment print, yet another reminder that central bank projections are lagging indicators in forward‑guidance clothing. Markets loved the bad news as a precursor of more cuts ahead, bolstered by this week’s second data point: headline CPI printed softer, which was all the excuse traders needed to lean into a fatter rate‑cut profile for 2026. ​

      The AI “it’s a bubble” bear porn is still good for clicks, but it is missing the only part that really matters for capital allocators: hyperscalers are shifting from self‑funding the capex arms race out of cash flow to tapping debt markets, quietly turning an earnings story into a balance‑sheet and credit‑cycle story that will not treat every member of the Mag 7 the same when someone inevitably overbuilds. This is now a capital‑structure trade, not a vibes‑about‑NVIDIA trade.​

      If you think AI is a bubble, use your imagination: it’s just getting started. OpenAI may overextend its capital reach, but $0-$12 billion in revenue in three years is breathtaking.

      And in the background, one ounce of silver now buys you a barrel of oil for the first time in decades, a pricing inversion that says as much about the market’s evolving hierarchy of “real” assets as it does about any single commodity trade. When the metals‑for‑molecules ratio looks this weird, it is usually telling you something about the regime, not just the ticker.

      None of these stories, on their own, move markets. Together, they point to a familiar pattern: surface calm masking structural strain in the system’s plumbing.

      MacroMashup paid members receive full weekly deep dives, portfolio frameworks, and early access to investor-grade analysis. If you want to understand how liquidity, policy, and capital structure actually shape returns, subscribe today. Already subscribed? Enjoy this week’s deep dive into the the real market driver this year and next—liquidity!

      Read More
      Markets Adjust to Policy Drift as Powell’s Successor Nears
      MacroMashup Newsletter
      3

      Markets Adjust to Policy Drift as Powell’s Successor Nears

      Neil Winward

      Metals outperform, bitcoin cools, and custom silicon reshapes tech leadership in a year defined by policy uncertainty.

      Markets have already priced next week’s rate cut, reducing the December meeting to a procedural event. The surprise is political rather than monetary. Donald Trump has telegraphed that he has selected Jerome Powell’s successor and will announce the new chair early next year. Investors are trading under two regimes at once: the Fed we have, and the Fed about to arrive.

      That transition matters. It introduces fresh uncertainty into term premia at a time when markets had hoped for clarity and stability. With the policy anchor shifting, asset leadership is starting to rearrange itself.

      Gold and silver are the first to reflect the drift. Both metals are breaking higher as investors hedge the possibility that real yields will not return to their pre-pandemic ranges. Bitcoin, despite its “hard money” narrative, has trailed metals and equities throughout 2025. In a year where geopolitical and policy risks dominate, assets with sovereign and central-bank sponsorship continue to outperform instruments that rely on sentiment or brand identity for support.

      Inside equities, the AI narrative is broadening. Google and Amazon are amplifying investments in custom silicon, reducing Nvidia’s dominance and creating a more distributed hardware ecosystem. The era of AI as a single-ticker trade is ending. As money cheapens and capex accelerates, the economics of who controls compute—and the energy required to run it—becomes a macro factor rather than a niche technical variable.

      Geopolitical risk remains a muted but persistent backdrop. The war in Ukraine continues with no clear endgame. Markets have partially priced it out, but it still shapes defense spending, energy flows, and Western political cohesion. None of this is peripheral; together, these dynamics form a single regime shift rather than disconnected storylines.

      The through-line is that the cloud is becoming physical.

      Compute is migrating from an abstract idea to a resource-heavy system of power lines, land, cooling, and policy. The market is beginning to price the shift from software narratives to the infrastructure that fuels them.

      This Week’s Deep Dive

      The full deep dive examines how these forces converge in a real project: a giga-scale, multi-fuel energy–compute campus—and why it illustrates the investment architecture behind a potential 2.5x clean-energy opportunity. To access the complete analysis and investor notes, become a paid subscriber for only $0.30 per day. If you’re not quite ready for that, remember you can try the 7-day free trial.

      Read More
      Sustainable energy project investment
      IRA Report To Smarter Investing
      Unlock the Opportunities of the Inflation Reduction Act!​ Are you ready to stay ahead in today's shifting economic landscape? Our comprehensive white paper breaks down the Inflation Reduction Act and reveals the key benefits, incentives, and strategies your business needs to capitalize on. Learn how to optimize your financial planning, leverage tax credits, and position your company for sustainable growth.
      Pre-order now to get the insights and actionable steps that can give your business a competitive edge.
      New Version Release Date: 12/10/2024
      Thank you! Your submission has been received!
      Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
      Close icon